The Recruiting Grind

It’s supposed to be the culmination of a young man’s hard work and sacrifice, but in a lot of cases, the young man’s biggest sacrifice is simply the ability to enjoy the experience of the recruitment process as a whole. For the lucky few young men who are in a position to choose their destination to play major college football, the experience can be one of distress, manipulation, and separation. The world of college football recruiting has turned into a massive business and year round pursuit of these top caliber athletes, and instead of being able to fully embrace it, recruits often find themselves in a position of withdrawal and isolation.

While the majority of kids that we talk to seem to still find some enjoyment in the process, the pressure that is placed upon them from fans, media, and schools recruiting them can be daunting at times. There were several instances in 2013 and previous years also, in which kids have declared a “media blackout” on Twitter or Facebook, letting all reporters know they will no longer be participating in any type of interview. Kids have also found ways to distance themselves from fans that flock to their Twitter and Facebook accounts letting them know why their school is the only one that makes sense, and how much they want to see them there.

Once a kid announces his verbal, that is when the real fun starts. Typically they have to deal with extreme remarks, wishes of failure by fans of schools they didn’t choose, and continued pressure and pursuit from those schools also. Of course the situation differs wildly from one kid to the next, and can range from minimally annoying to downright uncalled for. Here is what one top 150 player told us whose experience wasn’t as bad as most –

Since being verbally committed, the toughest part is telling so many coaches that visit you all the time that you are solid, and you don’t necessarily want to visit or that you’re not interested in what they are offering, and doing that in a nice, polite way. It’s definitely the toughest situations I deal with now.

While another recruit told us

It’s just the constant pressure from every coach, it never ends.

 

So while the above statements are more on the annoying and disruptive side, these are some of the easier situations that big time recruits have to deal with. We have spoken with many top current and prior 150 recruits over the last 3-4 months, and have been told stories of manipulation, dishonesty, and promises that are never fulfilled. These kids deal with this on a daily basis, and while some of it is to be expected, most of it is not. Another recruit relayed the story of coaches and media bad-mouthing other programs or just simply lying about other programs to sway the his allegiance, in hopes of getting that all mighty letter of intent. One recruit talked to us about getting over 150 calls and texts in a single day, and calls being made to his family, friends, and current coaches trying to convince him that XYZ school is where he needs to end up at.

Even if you take the fans and media out of the equation, these kids are dealing with multiple days of being away from what most of us would could consider normal. One recruit actually mentioned how this was the hardest part of it all

The worst part is the constant traveling and being away from friends and family on the weekends. Not that it’s not worth it, but you sure do lose a lot of free time

While another mentioned

It’s not just the travel, which is hard itself, but you really are giving up so much of your high school time. People don’t understand what type of pressure we feel, and a lot of that comes from people outside of our circle. At first it’s a lot of fun, but after awhile it starts to really become anything but fun. It just really becomes a grind because it seems everybody always wants something from you- always.

It’s easy to talk about how a lot of these kids seek out the publicity, and crave the attention, but truthfully in most of our conversations we had with these young men, that is simply not the truth. A lot of these kids have worked very hard, been blessed with talent, and want to utilize the opportunity to better themselves. Most of the kids we spoke to really just want coaches to be honest with them, and to be treated like anyone else.

We posed the question to one of the recruits if they thought there was a different way that recruiting should be approached, and here is his response –

I’m not really sure if there is another way to do it, but it probably needs to be done in way that doesn’t have such an impact on our everyday lives. It sounds like I’m whining, but I’m really not. It got to the point where I had to tell people that they could text or call me only on certain days, at certain hours, because it was happening all the time. Even with doing that, it still happens all the time.

As fans, we love to blame the kids for the spectacle that recruiting has become, but in reality a large percentage of the fault falls back on the media, as they have created this red carpet mentality with year round coverage, sites dedicated to just recruiting, and weeklong coverage of National Signing Day. We want it, some kids like it, so everyone wins, but that isn’t the truth. We label these kids before they even step foot onto campus, and in a lot of cases place unrealistic expectations upon them.

From the outside the simple view say’s these kids have it all, and maybe in some aspects they do. That doesn’t mean that we should forget that underneath the helmet and jersey they don on Saturdays, remains a young man who is just as susceptible to outside influences as the rest of us were at that age. As coaches, fans, and media, we need to remember that the texts that we send, the messages on Facebook and Twitter that find their way on their accounts from us, and the phone calls we make, in a small way deprive the kids the chance of just growing up normal, and for what? They simply play a sport at a high school or collegiate level.  We would like to thank all the kids that took the time to talk to us again, and out of respect we have granted them anonymity.

You may also like

18 Comments

  1. It’s amazing, a young 17-18 year old kid commits to ND, arrives and it’s not what he imagined and does not fit in or misses home or his girlfriend or family?

    So, TOO BAD, the cast in granite GOLDEN WORD “commitment,” entitles ANY NCAA SOVIET STYLE COLLEGE to hold the kid in a lock-down dorm 24/7? Well, just in case, we should have them sign a living will also while they here for benefit of the state? Why not?

    Why dry your tears little man, we have all that you will ever need here in college-prision: You should be thrilled we saved you from being a ‘horrible prevaricator!’ (Hmmm….I wonder if that line would word on our HONORABLE Pr_______ ? (I’ll let you fill in the blank!). Hahahaha!

    Furthermore, little man, just think of all the benefits you have here with us: Imaginary Union Card, Imaginary Full Coverage Hospital Insurance, Imaginary Retirement and an Imaginary Huge Salary to play for us? Woohoo!

    PLUS! We guarantee we will only beat you like a Soviet-Dog M-F not on weekends for underperforming…eh? Sign here and DO NOT CHANGE YOUR MIND!!! Oh, I forgot, please use this limited edition Melissa Harris-Perry pen!

    Thank you! Comrade! Welcome to Hostage 101!

    Satirical? Ask Cuban Hostages!

    1. You’ve seen a 30 second clip of highlights and have the kid in the hall of fame. Meanwhile BK has over 20 years of a proven track record, goes undefeated last year and you want him fired.

      As always your insight is amazing.

  2. In the USA, if a kid is of legal age (18) he can vote, enlist in the military, purchase a home, fire arm, or automobile (provided they have the funds) and be tried as an adult with in our legal system.

    But the NCAA says he cannot sign his letter of intent until a specified “Signing Day” set forth by them?

    To me it sounds like another case of the NCAA of infringing on the rights of our young people in order to make a few more bucks off them.

    These young people should be able to sign with whom ever they want, when they want, and where want, provided they are 18 or older, have a clean record, and meet all acedemic standards.

    These are constitutional rights set down by our forefathers, rights that I value, rights that you value, but somehow these same rights don’t apply to our 18yr olds?

    Sounds like a double standard, sounds hypocritiacl, sounds unlawful, sounds like another case of the money grubbing pencil-necks at the NCAA!

    How they are allowed to continue to get away with it is beyond me.

      1. I suggest that the legal rights of an 18 year old, who just happens to have played high school football, be given the same level of legitimacy as any other adult.

        If you are a high school football player,(High School Graduate) have a scholarship offer, are 18 years old, meet the requirements set down by the school, and want to sign your LOI immediately, then you should be entitled to sign immediately.

        What’s the big deal?

      2. Not really sure I follow. First, you said 18 and then they need to be a high school graduate. National signing day is well before they graduate.

        Also, the LOI is binding where a verbal is not. Imagine an 18 year old in his junior year signing a LOI with a school, under your rules. So much can change over that time. Once they sign, if they want to leave they need to sit out a year.

        I think the later they sign actually protects the kids rights not hurts them. I guess if CBB is fine with two signing periods then it could work in CFB, but just not sure i understand your argument. Then again, I’ve had a few pints.

      3. NDS,

        Yes, Signing day is before most graduate.

        But their admittance into college and the scholarship fullfillment requirment is still based on graduating with an acceptable GPA.(and maintaining that GPA)

        The point I was trying to make was about the pre-set date selected by the NCAA for when a player can sign.

        For example… A 18 year old high school football player graduates early. (Like many now do in December/January) He holds a scholarship offer to the school he wishes to attend.

        I say it should be his right to sign his LOI as soon as his
        high school Graduation and GPA is of official record.

        Sure, this might not be the best approch for everyone, but for those where it is, they should be allowed to exercise their right to do so.

        But the NCAA says otherwise.

        The way I see it, the NCAA
        forces thier signing date on the players because they want their “National Signing Day” and the revenue it generates.

        They want to use the phsyical attributes, acedemic records, highlight high school film, quotes, statements, social and economic status, religious beliefs, public records, and photographs of these young adults in order to promote their dog and pony show they call National Signing Day.

        They, their associates, and their sponsors make untold amounts of money, while offering no monitary compensation whats so ever to the student athlete who makes their National Signing Day Extravaganza possible to begin with.

        Not really so sure I see that as actually protecting the kids or their rights.

        Seems more like a case of infringement of rights and exploitation for monitary gain to me.

        But that’s just me.

        Stay thirsty my friend!

  3. The main reason I feel this way is that one singular commitment has far reaching effects on many other people(like other comitments) & to not uphold that proclomation can very well deny opportunity to others…..especially under certain timing restrictions. Plus its just the right thing to do and sends a horrible message to condone the act of not living up to your word/commitment.

  4. I feel that the NCAA should ban the “verbal”. An early signing period could be a positive step but an announced or proclaimed commitment should be just that.

  5. I would like to see the ncaa have a rule that when a kid verbals to a school he signs a temporary paper binding him to that school. Kid has to honor his verbal commitment he made to a school. Kid can’t switch his pledge, take visits have contact with any coaches outside of the school he verbals, to. The only exception a player can back out of his verbal at anytime would be if any coaches on the school he verballed to leaves. This would cut down on all of this poaching and players would be more firm in their commitment if they know they can’t backout. Also, would teach kids the value of making and keeping a commitment.

    1. Pete,

      Yeah, let’s waterboard the kid for thinking he had a change of heart for a better fit elsewhere. Do we send back all our recruits who flipped for ND under your new rule?

      Welcome to Pete’s NEW Amerika. Someone else decides for you? Not with my grandson you don’t pal! You need to relocate to Cuba! Happy Trails!

    2. A great idea, but we have secured a number of recruits who have ‘de committed’. I think an early signing period would help. You are also right in saying our young people NEED to realize giving their word MEANS JUST THAT. SAug. 1st.

      1. poppyitis,

        BS…Mr.MEANS JUST THAT, these are USA kids who have the RIGHT to choose the college of their choice, at anytime and at any juncture over anyone’s delusional football greed! PERIOD!

  6. Very good article and some great points. I think we, as fans, often forget these are really just kids and though they have opportunities that most of their peers do not, they are still kids who want to be able to finish up their last couple of years in high school as normal kids and not spend every moment they have on the phone, text, or emailing with the media or college coaches. I as a fan can at least say I have never commented on a recruits FB page or tweeted at a recruit. I kind of find that creepy a bit.

  7. Very good article and some great points. I think we, as fans, often forget these are really just kids and though they have opportunities that most of their peers do not, they are still kids who want to be able to finish up their last couple of years in high school as normal kids and not spend every moment they have on the phone, text, or emailing with the media or college coaches. I as a fan can at least say I have never commented on a recruits FB page or tweeted at a recruit. I kind of find that creepy a bit.

  8. Very good article and some great points. I think we, as fans, often forget these are really just kids and though they have opportunities that most of their peers do not, they are still kids who want to be able to finish up their last couple of years in high school as normal kids and not spend every moment they have on the phone, text, or emailing with the media or college coaches. I as a fan can at least say I have never commented on a recruits FB page or tweeted at a recruit. I kind of find that creepy a bit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button